1955-1959 Father Damian Glenn, OSB
1959-1964 Father Dunstan Curtis, OSB
1964-1971 Father Michael Feeney, OSB
1971-1975 Father Matthew Naumes
1975-1980 Father John Scott, OSB
1980-1984 Dr. John Ishii
1984-2005 Dr. David Spangler
2005-2008 Dr. Douglas Astolfi
2008 Bryan M. Johnston, J.D. (Deceased; never formally inaugurated)
2008-2008 Dr. David Spangler (Interim)
2009 Dr. Roy F. Heynderickx